By the PrototypeVerdict Test Team
Every AI app builder we’ve tested, in one filterable table. We gave Lovable, Bolt, Base44 and Softr the same three prompts on Oct 29, 2026, and Replit on Oct 29–30: a client intake portal, an invoice tracker and a landing page. Every score, time and usage figure for Lovable, Bolt, Base44, Replit and Softr comes from that test log. We later ran the same three prompts in Claude Code and in Claude chat artifacts on a Claude Pro plan on Nov 10, 2026. Those two surfaces are not scored: the run was on a different day, and Claude Code is a terminal workflow rather than a hosted builder. Claude Code is the pick for readers who are comfortable in a terminal and want local code they run themselves; it had no one-click deploy in our runs. Chat artifacts got previews fast, but the portal build only simulated auth and kept data in memory.
This page is the multi-tool table, including a Lovable vs Base44 vs Bolt view. For a dedicated pairwise write-up of the same three test apps, read our Base44 vs Bolt comparison.
Filter the AI app builders
Pick what matters to you. The cards and the full table below update together. Prices are in USD, from each tool’s pricing page.
No tool matches every filter. Try “Any” on one of them, or reset the filters.
Hands-on tested Oct 29, 2026
Lovable
8.4/10Best for: Code ownership and growing a real product
- Plan we tested Pro, 100 credits ($25/mo)
- Free plan Yes: 5 build credits a day, up to 30 a month
- Cheapest paid plan Pro, 100 credits: $25/mo ($21/mo billed annually)
- Apps working (of 3) 3 of 3
- Beginners #2 in our beginners list
Hands-on tested Oct 29, 2026
Bolt
8.4/10Best for: Starting for $0 and downloading your code
- Plan we tested Free ($0/mo)
- Free plan Yes: 1M tokens a month, 300K a day
- Cheapest paid plan Pro (entry tier): $25/mo ($18/mo billed annually)
- Apps working (of 3) 3 of 3
- Beginners #3 in our beginners list
Hands-on tested Oct 29, 2026
Base44
8.1/10Best for: The simplest all-in-one setup for an internal tool or portal
- Plan we tested Builder ($50/mo)
- Free plan Yes: 25 message credits a month, up to 5 apps
- Cheapest paid plan Starter: $20/mo ($16/mo billed annually)
- Apps working (of 3) 3 of 3
- Beginners #1 in our beginners list
Hands-on tested Oct 29–30, 2026
Replit
7.5/10Best for: Trying an AI app builder for $0 when you can spread the work over several days
- Plan we tested Free ($0/mo)
- Free plan Yes: daily Agent credits up to a monthly cap (size not published)
- Cheapest paid plan Core: $20/mo ($18/mo billed annually)
- Apps working (of 3) 3 of 3
- Beginners Not ranked
Hands-on tested Oct 29, 2026 (Basic plan)
Softr
Not scored yet: our tests need Softr ProBest for: Not judged yet: see our Basic-plan test notes
- Plan we tested Basic ($25/mo)
- Free plan Yes: 5 AI credits a month
- Cheapest paid plan Basic: $25/mo ($19/mo billed annually)
- Apps working (of 3) 1 of 3
- Beginners Not ranked
Hands-on tested Nov 10, 2026 (not scored)
Claude Code
Not scored (tested Nov 10, 2026)Best for: Readers comfortable in a terminal who want local code they run themselves
- Plan we tested Claude Pro ($20/mo billed monthly)
- Free plan Yes, but Claude Code is not included on Free
- Cheapest paid plan Pro: $20/mo ($17/mo billed annually)
- Apps working (of 3) 3 of 3
- Beginners Not ranked
Hands-on tested Nov 10, 2026 (not scored)
Claude (chat artifacts)
Not scored (tested Nov 10, 2026)Best for: A fast clickable preview inside a chat, not a hosted multi-user app
- Plan we tested Claude Pro ($20/mo billed monthly)
- Free plan Yes: can create artifacts; we did not separately test Free (docs: saving data needs a paid plan)
- Cheapest paid plan Pro: $20/mo ($17/mo billed annually)
- Apps working (of 3) 2 of 3 (portal preview only: simulated auth and in-memory data)
- Beginners Not ranked
The full comparison table
Scroll sideways on a phone. Scores are out of 10. “–” means the tool wasn’t scored.
| Tool | Status | Last tested | Overall | Ease of use | Output quality | Pricing value | Backend & data | Code ownership & export | Plan we tested | Free plan | Cheapest paid plan | Apps working (of 3) | Bug-fix messages | Time to 3 working apps | Plan allowance used (3 apps) | Real database by default | Client sees only own records | Code export | Beginners |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lovable | Tested and scored | Oct 29, 2026 | 8.4 | 8.5 | 9.0 | 8.0 | 8.0 | 8.0 | Pro, 100 credits ($25/mo) | Yes: 5 build credits a day, up to 30 a month | Pro, 100 credits: $25/mo ($21/mo yearly) | 3 of 3 | 1 | About 16 min | 5.5 of 100 balance credits (plus that day's 5 free daily credits) | 2 of 3 apps (invoices in the browser until asked) | Passed | ZIP (100 files) and Git sync; download needs a paid plan | #2 in our beginners list |
| Bolt | Tested and scored | Oct 29, 2026 | 8.4 | 7.5 | 9.5 | 7.5 | 8.5 | 9.0 | Free ($0/mo) | Yes: 1M tokens a month, 300K a day | Pro (entry tier): $25/mo ($18/mo yearly) | 3 of 3 | 1 | About 20–21 min | 100% of the 300K daily limit (30% of the 1M monthly tokens) | All 3 apps | Not run | ZIP (30 files) on the Free plan | #3 in our beginners list |
| Base44 | Tested and scored | Oct 29, 2026 | 8.1 | 9.0 | 9.5 | 7.0 | 9.5 | 4.5 | Builder ($50/mo) | Yes: 25 message credits a month, up to 5 apps | Starter: $20/mo ($16/mo yearly) | 3 of 3 | 0 | About 22 min | About 8.75 of 250 message credits (~3.5%) | All 3 apps | Passed | ZIP (108 files), but it relies on Base44's backend; needs Builder | #1 in our beginners list |
| Replit | Tested and scored | Oct 29–30, 2026 | 7.5 | 6.0 | 9.0 | 7.5 | 7.0 | 8.0 | Free ($0/mo) | Yes: daily Agent credits up to a monthly cap (size not published) | Core: $20/mo ($18/mo yearly) | 3 of 3 | 2 (1 fixed, 1 not possible on Free) | About 30–34 min, over 2 days | Daily free quota: 86% used by build 1, hit 100% about 3 min into build 2; 82% of day 2 | 2 of 3 apps (invoices in the browser only) | Not run | Download as zip and a Git tool seen on Free; not used | Not ranked |
| Softr | Tested, not scored yet | Oct 29, 2026 | Not scored yet: our tests need Softr Pro | – | – | – | – | – | Basic ($25/mo) | Yes: 5 AI credits a month | Basic: $25/mo ($19/mo yearly) | 1 of 3 | 5 (1 on the portal, 4 on the tracker) | Portal and tracker never fully worked | 4.01 of 10 included AI credits (40%) | All 3 apps | Failed on Basic | None (data exports as CSV) | Not ranked |
| Claude Code | Tested, not scored | Nov 10, 2026 | Not scored (tested Nov 10, 2026) | – | – | – | – | – | Claude Pro ($20/mo) | Yes, but Claude Code is not included on Free | Pro: $20/mo ($17/mo yearly) | 3 of 3 | 0 | About 13 min 24 s of CLI time (portal independently working ~10 min) | CLI list-price total $3.44 across 65 turns; session/week % not shown by the CLI | 1 of 3 in a database (portal: local SQLite; invoice tracker: browser only; landing-page form: a local file) | Passed | The project folder itself; no ZIP button or Git button in our runs | Not ranked |
| Claude (chat artifacts) | Tested, not scored | Nov 10, 2026 | Not scored (tested Nov 10, 2026) | – | – | – | – | – | Claude Pro ($20/mo) | Yes: can create artifacts; we did not separately test Free (docs: saving data needs a paid plan) | Pro: $20/mo ($17/mo yearly) | 2 of 3 (portal preview only) | 2 | Fastest previews (~2 min 44 s / ~3 min 49 s / ~3 min); portal backend failed | Session 0% → 12%, week 0% → 2%, $0 extra credits | No real multi-user database (portal: in-memory / simulated auth; invoice tracker: artifact storage with localStorage fallback; landing-page form: browser only after a fix) | Failed (admin view unrestricted; reload wiped portal data) | HTML / Markdown / PDF export; share left private. Not a hosted multi-user deploy | Not ranked |
Overall = ease of use 25% + output quality 25% + pricing value 20% + backend and data 15% + code ownership and export 15% (how we test). Overall scores within half a point are close, so pick on fit. The plans weren’t the same: Lovable ran on Pro ($25/mo), Base44 on Builder ($50/mo), Bolt and Replit on Free ($0), and Softr on Basic ($25/mo), all billed monthly. Credits, message credits, tokens and AI credits are each tool’s own unit, so compare the share of the plan used, not the raw numbers. Softr isn’t scored yet because our tests need Softr Pro. Claude Code and Claude chat artifacts were tested on Claude Pro on Nov 10, 2026, and are not scored: that run was on a different day from the scored tools, and Claude Code is a terminal workflow rather than a hosted builder. An earlier Free-plan sign-up attempt on Oct 29, 2026, was refused; the November builds used an existing Pro account.
The results in five charts





Quick picks
- Fewest surprises for a first app: Base44. 0 bug-fix messages and a real database in all three apps (tested on Builder, $50/mo).
- Keep and move your code later: Lovable. Fastest of the scored tools in our test (about 16 min), with code download and Git sync (tested on Pro, $25/mo).
- Start for $0: Bolt. All three apps worked on its Free plan, then it hit its 300K daily token limit. Replit’s free plan also built all three, but its daily quota stretched our test over two days.
- A client portal where each client sees only their own records: Base44 or Lovable. Both passed our separate-client check; Softr failed it on Basic, and we haven’t run it on Bolt or Replit. Claude Code’s local portal also passed that check on Nov 10, 2026; Claude chat artifacts did not (the admin view was unrestricted, and reload wiped the data).
- Comfortable in a terminal, want local code: Claude Code (not scored). All three prompts worked with 0 fix-up messages on Claude Pro on Nov 10, 2026, including a real local SQLite portal. There was no one-click public deploy. Chat artifacts on the same plan were faster to a preview, but the portal only simulated auth and kept data in memory.
Go deeper
- Head to head: Bolt vs Lovable · Base44 vs Lovable · Base44 vs Bolt · Lovable vs Claude Code · All comparisons
- Data: usage study and CSV · pricing tracker · credit and cost calculator
- New to this? Best AI app builders for beginners · Vibe coding for beginners
- Want the research-based tools too? AI vs no-code app builders: 8 tools compared.
Limits: one run per app per tool, small unpublished test apps, fake data only. Prices change; check each tool’s pricing page before you buy. Every review linked above lists what we didn’t test.
Tested: Oct 29–30, 2026 (Claude Code and Claude chat artifacts: Nov 10, 2026). Pricing checked: Oct 29, 2026 (Replit: Oct 30, 2026; Claude: Nov 10, 2026); Lovable, Bolt, Base44, Replit and Softr list prices re-confirmed Nov 11, 2026. Published: Oct 30, 2026. Updated: Nov 16, 2026.